If a Deputy Commissioner (DC) — who is the top district administrator — calls all government employees for a pen-down strike, it is considered a misuse of power.
📌 Why it is Misuse of Power?
-
Role of DC
-
The Deputy Commissioner (or District Magistrate) is the representative of the government in a district.
-
His/her duty is to ensure law & order, administration, and smooth functioning of offices, not to disrupt them.
-
-
Strike by Government Employees
-
Government employees are restricted from striking under Rule 22 of the Jammu & Kashmir Government Employees Conduct Rules (similar to Central rules).
-
Strikes affect public services, health, education, revenue, and law & order, which DC is supposed to protect.
-
-
Misuse of Authority
-
DC has administrative powers over employees but cannot direct them to go on strike.
-
Using his position to paralyze government work = abuse of official position.
-
-
Legal Angle
-
Such an act may fall under misconduct and even attract disciplinary action under service rules.
-
Citizens could also move to High Court against such arbitrary misuse, since it violates Right to Public Services.
-
📌 Key Point for Exams / Notes
👉 If a Deputy Commissioner directs employees to observe a pen-down strike, it is misuse of power because it goes against his administrative duty, service conduct rules, and public interest.
If DC Informally Calls for a Strike (No Written Order)
-
No Official Record
-
Since no written order or official circular exists, it is difficult to prove legally.
-
In court or inquiry, lack of documentary proof makes the case weak.
-
-
Misuse of Position (Ethically & Administratively)
-
Even without written proof, if employees know the DC informally directed or pressured them, it is still a misuse of authority.
-
A DC is expected to maintain neutrality and continuity of governance, not encourage disruption.
-
-
Risk to Employees
-
Employees who follow such “informal strike calls” are also violating service conduct rules.
-
Later, they cannot defend themselves by saying “DC verbally told us” unless they have evidence.
-
-
Practical Reality
-
In administration, such practices are common but unofficial.
-
Everyone “knows” but no one can “prove.” This creates a grey zone — morally wrong, but legally safe for the DC unless whistleblowers or collective complaints arise.
-
📌 Key Point
👉 If a DC informally calls employees for a strike without written proof, it is still misuse of power ethically and administratively, but hard to establish legally unless employees collectively testify or leak recordings/messages.